Chandigarh Archive

Man dies during PM’s PGIMER visit, police shrug off blame

Chandigarh/New Delhi, Nov 3 – The Chandigarh police Tuesday sought to clarify that they had no responsibility for the death of a kidney patient who allegedly died outside Post-Graduate Institute of Medical Education and Research (PGIMER) here because the security measures for the prime minister’s visit barred the entry to the hospital.

‘After getting the information, an executive magistrate was deputed to conduct an enquiry. As per the findings, there was no lapse on the part of security personnel. In fact, the patient was attended to by doctors and he died during the treatment,’ according to a police statement, issued here late Tuesday evening.

‘Tight security arrangements were made for the visiting VVIP but the normal traffic was not at all disturbed. Traffic was stopped only for a few minutes at only one gate,’ the statement added.

The Prime Minister’s Office (PMO) Tuesday sought a report from PGIMER on the death of this patient, who could not enter the hospital because of security measures in place for Prime Minister Manmohan Singh’s visit.

‘The PMO is saddened at the death of a patient at the Post-Graduate Institute of Medical Education and Research today during the visit of the prime minister. A full report has been asked for,’ said a senior official Tuesday.

Sumit Prakash Verma, 32, died after the vehicle carrying him could not enter the emergency area of the PGIMER in time for treatment, his relatives said.

They alleged that their vehicle carrying Verma from Ambala, 45 km from Chandigarh, was stopped at different gates of the institute, due to which crucial time was wasted.

‘We came near the PGIMER when the prime minister’s motorcade was entering. The road near the emergency was sealed by police and we were told to use another gate. At that gate, we were told to go to a third place and then directed to go to the original gate. This delayed our reaching the hospital and he died,’ Richa Verma, a relative, told reporters.

Sources in the PMO told IANS that security personnel could not gauge how critical Verma was as he was not travelling in an ambulance.

Verma was suffering from a major kidney ailment and had breathing trouble. He is survived by his wife and two children.

Manmohan Singh was here for the 30th convocation of the PGIMER.

However, the hospital’s security officials maintained that they did not stop any vehicle from entering the premises.

‘We did not stop any person or any vehicle from entering PGIMER. Heavy security was deployed, but our officials did not harass anybody unnecessarily,’ P.C. Sharma, PGIMER’s in-charge, told IANS Tuesday evening.

Ajay Chautala resigns from Rajya Sabha

Chandigarh, Nov 3 – Indian National Lok Dal (INLD) secretary general Ajay Singh Chautala resigned his membership of the Rajya Sabha Tuesday.

Chautala, elder son of INLD leader and former chief minister Om Prakash Chautala, was last month elected to the Haryana assembly from the Dabwali seat.

His term in the Rajya Sabha was to end in August 2010.

Chautala had earlier been Lok Sabha member from Bhiwani parliamentary constituency in Haryana.

The INLD won 31 seats in last month’s assembly election in Haryana. The Haryana assembly has 90 members.

PM talks education, health, his security blamed for death

Chandigarh, Nov 3 – On a hectic six-hour trip to the city where he once resided, Prime Minister Manmohan Singh Tuesday talked of deficiencies in effective healthcare and higher education, but his tight security was blamed for contributing to the death of a young man who failed to reach the hospital in time owing to blocked traffic.

Ambala resident Sumit Prakash Verma, 32, died as over-zealous security personnel did not allow his vehicle to reach the emergency area of the Post-Graduate Institute of Medical Education and Research (PGIMER) as the prime minister had arrived there to address the 30th convocation of the premier health institute.

Verma’s relatives blamed the prime minister’s security for wasting over two hours of theirs, the time during which the victim, who was suffering from kidney, breathing and heart problems, died.

The Prime Minister’s Office (PMO) reacted instantly in New Delhi saying: ‘The PMO is saddened at the death of a patient at the Post-Graduate Institute of Medical Education and Research today (Tuesday) during the visit of the prime minister. A full report has been asked for.’

Coming to his alma mater, the Panjab University, after many years made the prime minister feel a ‘little emotional’. But that did not stop him from questioning the quality of higher education being imparted by institutions in the country.

Addressing faculty and students of the university where he once studied and later taught, Manmohan Singh, wearing his trademark white kurta-pyjama and a black half-jacket with light-blue turban, said: ‘A major problem that we face is in the quality of higher education that our institutions impart. Unfortunately, most of them produce pass-outs who are nowhere near international standards.’

The prime minister was honoured by the PU with a Doctor of Law (honoris causa) at a special convocation here. Later, he laid the foundation stone of a multi-purpose auditorium and examination centre. He also met with his contemporaries in PU from his student and teaching days and also some of his own students.

The prime minister said: ‘In fact, one dimension of the quality deficit is the difficulty being faced in recruiting top class faculty for the new IIMs, IITs, central universities and other such institutions that the government has decided to establish in the last five years.’

Earlier, addressing the 30th convocation of the Post-Graduate Institute of Medical Education and Research (PGIMER) here, the prime minister said that even though critical indicators of health had shown consistent improvement over the years, India did not compare favourably with other countries.

‘It is also a fact that in the public sector today we are spending one percent of the GDP on healthcare. It has been our goal to raise it to two to three percent. Both the central and state governments have to work hard to achieve this goal.

‘Our progress has been much less than what we would have liked to achieve and are capable of achieving. It also does not compare well with what a number of other countries, particularly in Southeast Asia, have achieved,’ he said.

‘A review of the National Rural Health Mission points to the acute shortage of human resources at various levels in the health sector – specialists, doctors, nurses and paramedics. To address this deficiency, the government has taken a number of initiatives. More medical colleges and nursing schools are being established, particularly in the less developed states,’ he said.

The prime minister asked institutes like the PGIMER to reach out to the common man by laying emphasis on preventive healthcare as curative healthcare proved costly.

‘The mission of PGI will remain incomplete unless the interest of the common man is addressed effectively and purposefully. Only when the lives of the common people, be they in Tripura or the tribal areas of Chhattisgarh, are touched by your research and the most underprivileged child in your ward goes back home satisfied with your care, will your mission be truly accomplished.’

Walk down memory lane for PM, old colleagues

Chandigarh, Nov 3 – Prime Minister Manmohan Singh’s visit to his alma mater Panjab University Tuesday was full of emotions and nostalgic feelings for both him as well as for those who had spent days together with him then in the campus.

Right at the onset of his speech, the prime minister said: ‘Please forgive me if I become a little bit emotional as I am amidst those people with whom I had interacted and remained in contact both as a teacher and as a student.’

Citing his old friends present at the occasion, he added: ‘Mr. Bhamba, Mr. Shergil, Mr. Harnam Singh, Mr. Puri… all are in front of me and I am down the memory lane, remembering the beautiful period that I spent here.’

Manmohan Singh was here Tuesday to lay the foundation stone of a multi-purpose auditorium at the PU and to receive the degree of Doctors of Laws (honorary).

His Former students and colleagues were also enthusiastic about his visit.

‘Last time I had met him in New Delhi, around three to four years back. Today’s brief meeting was very emotional and yes, at the same time very refreshing. I just shook hands and wished him good luck as he is holding the most responsible position in the country,’ H.S. Shergil, a student of Manmohan Singh in the PU’s Economics department, told IANS.

‘I always remained very close to him as I was the topper of my class. Moreover, I was a part of the last batch that was taught by him in 1966,’ added Shergil, who retired as teaher from the same department.

Madan Mohan Puri, a colleague of Manmohan Singh, told IANS: ‘I just wished him and did not try to talk to him much keeping in mind his busy schedule. He was my neighbour while living in the PU campus and our families still share a very close bond.’

‘As a human being, he is still the same man; very affectionate, sincere and concerned, but as a statesman he has touched heights. He used to call me Madan Babu and today also he addressed me like this,’ he added.

Manmohan Singh studied in the PU till the post-graduate level. He got his bachelor’s degree in Economics (honours) in 1952 and Master’s degree in the same subject in 1954, securing the first position in the university in each examination.

From 1957 to 1965, Manmohan Singh taught here at the PU’s economics department and rose to position of professor at a young age of 32.

R.P. Bhamba, a former faculty member of the university, said: ‘I had seen Manmohan very closely. When he was studying in PU, he enjoyed very cordial relations with some young teachers of that time. He was one of the most talented and best student a teacher can have.’

‘We had celebrated various festivals and occasions together. Today he was very busy, so I did not interact with him very freely,’ he added.

PM questions quality of higher education in India

Chandigarh, Nov 3 – Coming to his alma mater, the Panjab University, after many years made Prime Minister Manmohan Singh feel a ‘little emotional’. But that did not stop him from questioning the quality of higher education being imparted by institutions in the country.

Addressing faculty and students of the university where he once studied and later taught, Manmohan Singh, wearing his trademark white kurta-payjama and a black half-jacket with light-blue turban, said: ‘A major problem that we face is in the quality of higher education that our institutions impart. Unfortunately, most of them produce pass-outs who are nowhere near international standards.’

The prime minister was honoured by the PU with a Doctor of Law (honoris causa) at a special convocation here. Later, he laid the foundation stone of a multi-purpose auditorium and examination centre.

The prime minister said: ‘In fact, one dimension of the quality deficit is the difficulty being faced in recruiting top class faculty for the new IIMs, IITs, central universities and other such institutions that the government has decided to establish in the last five years.’

‘Even if we meet our targets of higher access and enrolment, even if we spend huge amounts on higher education and even if we open a large number of new institutions, this issue of quality will not get addressed by itself.’

He said that to overcome this deficit of quality in higher education, the central government has come out with a ‘very progressive pay package for attracting and retaining talented faculty’. He added that the central government was fully committed to structural reforms in higher education.

‘I do recognize that we have a mammoth task ahead in pursuing our goal of providing access to good education to every citizen in the country. This is true of higher education also.’

He noted that at present, in any year, only about 12 per cent of the students who complete secondary education enrol for higher education. ‘This does not compare well with the figure of about 70 per cent in some developed countries. It is also much lower than the figure of about 20 per cent in some southeast Asian countries. We must increase this proportion,’ he said.

‘We must also address the existing imbalances in our higher education system. Today, nearly half of the institutions of higher learning exist in only five states, nearly 70 per cent of the total intake capacity for professional courses exists in another five states. There is a large gender gap in enrolments for higher education, and there are large intra-state imbalances too. We must address these deficiencies.’

The prime minister told students in the audience that they were a ‘privileged lot’ to be studying ‘in one of the best universities in the country’.

Saying that he was ‘greatly indebted’ to the PU, the prime minister said that he had spent ‘some of the best years’ of his life here.

Punjab shutdown against riots hits normal life (Roundup)

Chandigarh/Amritsar, Nov 3 – Trains were stopped, road traffic was hit while schools and colleges were closed in many Punjab towns as radical groups called for a shutdown Tuesday to protest the denial of justice to families of the thousands killed in the 1984 anti-Sikh riots.

The strike, however, passed off peacefully, police officers said in Chandigarh.

The strike call was given by the Dal Khalsa and was supported by the Khalsa Action Committee (KAC), Damdami Taksal, Delhi Sikh Gurdwara Prabandhak Committee (DSGPC), All India Sikh Students Federation (AISSF) and Shiromani Panthic Council.

‘We have not got justice for Sikhs in the last 25 years. We want the deaf government in the centre to listen to our demands. We will ask the UN to intervene and seek justice for Sikhs,’ Dal Khalsa leader Kanwarpal Singh said.

The KAC and AISSF later claimed that the strike was ‘complete’ in Punjab and thanked people for it.

Dal Khalsa chief Harcharan Singh Dhami, AISSF President Karnail Singh Peer Mohammad and KAC chief Mohkam Singh said in a joint statement: ‘The strike has been supported by everyone in Punjab. People believe that 1984 was a Sikh genocide and Punjab people are together fighting against it.’

Dal Khalsa activists stopped trains at the Amritsar railway station Tuesday morning.

The Amritsar-New Delhi Shatabdi Express, Sachkhand Express, Dadar Express, Superfast Express and other trains were stopped. Scores of Dal Khalsa members squatted on the rail tracks.

The Shatabdi Express was later cancelled by railway authorities, leaving hundreds of passengers stranded. Some other trains were allowed to leave by railway authorities in the afternoon after the protestors melted away.

Shops in some areas of major cities, petrol pumps and a few banks also remained closed in the first half of the day. Schools in various cities were shut by the authorities. Bus services and other modes of public transport were also affected.

Police in Amritsar stopped about 50 Sikh youths on motorcycles brandishing kirpans (swords). They were intercepted near the Hall Gate and their kirpans were confiscated.

There was a minor clash between the two sides but the youths were allowed to leave.

Road and railway traffic was also affected near Rajpura town, 40 km from Chandigarh. Punjab Chief Minister Parkash Singh Badal urged the protestors to be peaceful.

The strike had partial effect in the industrial and commercial city of Ludhiana. Protesters blocked one over-bridge in the heart of the city and shops remained closed in some areas.

Shops and other establishments were shut in parts of Moga, Sangrur and some other towns.

The Dal Khalsa criticised the the Shiromani Gurudwara Prabandhak Committee (SGPC), the mini parliament of Sikhs, for keeping its offices open.

India’s prime minister Indira Gandhi was assassinated by her Sikh guards Oct 31, 1984. This led to widespread riots against Sikhs, leaving thousands dead and homeless.

Punjab targeting 140 lakh tonnes paddy procurement

Chandigarh, Nov 3 – Punjab is targeting to procure more than 140 lakh tonnes of paddy this season, the Chief Minister’s office here said Tuesday.

Government procurement agencies and private millers have procured 114 lakh tonnes till Monday evening, the office of Chief Minister Parkash Singh Badal said.

According to food and supplies department officials, the procurement so far was satisfactory given the late arrival of paddy in the grain markets. Officially, the procurement started Oct 1 this season.

Last year, considered a good crop year, about 118 lakh tonnes of paddy had been procured in the corresponding period.

The officials said farmers have been paid over Rs.10,750 crore for the paddy purchased so far.

The state government and procurement agencies are upbeat about paddy output despite earlier concerns that the yield could fall owing to deficient rainfall and drought-like conditions this year.

Over 98 percent of the paddy arriving in over 1,600 grain markets across Punjab has been bought by government agencies – five from the Punjab government and the centre’s Food Corp of India (FCI).

Patiala led among the 20 Punjab districts with over 12 lakh tonnes of procurement, which is expected to continue till next month in the state.

Man dies during PM’s PGIMER visit, PMO asks for report

New Delhi/Chandigarh, Nov 3 – The Prime Minister’s Office (PMO) Tuesday sought a report from Chandigarh’s Post-Graduate Institute of Medical Education and Research (PGIMER) on the death of a kidney patient, who could not enter the hospital because of security measures in place for Prime Minister Manmohan Singh’s visit.

‘The PMO is saddened at the death of a patient at the Post-Graduate Institute of Medical Education and Research today during the visit of the prime minister. A full report has been asked for,’ said a senior official.

Sumit Prakash Verma, 32, died after the vehicle carrying him could not enter the emergency area of the PGIMER in time for treatment, his relatives said.

They alleged that their vehicle carrying Verma from Ambala, 45 km from Chandigarh, was stopped at different gates of the institute due to which crucial time was wasted.

‘We came near the PGIMER when the prime minister’s motorcade was entering. The road near the emergency was sealed by police and we were told to use another gate. At that gate we were told to go to a third place and then directed to go to the original gate. This delayed our reaching the hospital and he died,’ Richa Verma, a relative, told reporters.

Sources in the PMO told IANS that security personnel could not gauge how critical Verma was as he was not travelling in an ambulance.

Verma was suffering from a major kidney ailment and had breathing trouble. He is survived by his wife and two children.

Manmohan Singh was here for the 44th convocation of the PGIMER.

Hospital officials were not available for comment as they were busy with the prime minister’s visit.

Human resource shortage affecting rural health mission: PM

Chandigarh, Nov 3 – Prime Minister Manmohan Singh Tuesday admitted that the shortage of human resources was becoming an impediment in strengthening the public health delivery system through the National Rural Health Mission (NRHM).

Addressing the 44th convocation of the Post-Graduate Institute of Medical Education and Research (PGIMER) here, the prime minister said that even though critical indicators of health had shown consistent improvement over the years, India did not compare favourably with other countries.

‘It is also a fact that in the public sector today we are spending one percent of the GDP on healthcare. It has been our goal to raise it to two to three percent. Both the central and state governments have to work hard to achieve this goal.

‘Our progress has been much less than what we would have liked to achieve and are capable of achieving. It also does not compare well with what a number of other countries, particularly in Southeast Asia, have achieved,’ he said.

The prime minister said a number of steps are being taken to address the deficiencies of the NRHM.

‘A review of the National Rural Health Mission points to the acute shortage of human resources at various levels in the health sector – specialists, doctors, nurses and paramedics. This is one of the biggest impediments to strengthening of the public health delivery system and scaling up access to healthcare.

‘To address this deficiency, the government has taken a number of initiatives. More medical colleges and nursing schools are being established, particularly in the less developed states. The student-teacher ratio has been enhanced in specialties and super-specialties from the current level of 1:1 to 2:1. This is expected to increase the number of post-graduate specialists by almost 5,000 from the existing level of 13,000 within a short period of time,’ he said.

The prime minister asked institutes like the PGIMER to reach out to the common man by laying emphasis on preventive healthcare as curative healthcare proved costly.

‘The mission of PGI will remain incomplete unless the interest of the common man is addressed effectively and purposefully. Institutions like yours must link more effectively with the community and address its needs.’

He added: ‘Only when the lives of the common people, be they in Tripura or the tribal areas of Chhattisgarh, are touched by your research and the most underprivileged child in your ward goes back home satisfied with your care, will your mission be truly accomplished.’

Union Health Minister Ghulam Nabi Azad said that PGI had made a name for itself in healthcare in the northwestern region of the country.

‘It is not (for) nothing that patients in north-west India say if their disease cannot be treated and cured in PGI, it is doubtful if anyone else can treat it,’ Azad said.

Degrees were awarded to 361 students of the PGIMER on this occasion.

Governors of Punjab and Haryana, S.F. Rodrigues and Jagannath Pahadia, the chief ministers of both states, Parkash Singh Badal and Bhupinder Singh Hooda, were present on the occasion.

Family blames PM’s security for man’s death

Chandigarh, Nov 3 – Tight security measures for Prime Minister Manmohan Singh’s visit to a premier health research institute here Tuesday cost a man his life, the victim’s family has alleged.

Sumit Prakash Verma, 32, died after the vehicle carrying him could not enter the emergency area of the Post-graduate Institute of Medical Education and Research (PGIMER) in time for treatment, his relatives said.

They alleged that their vehicle carrying Verma from Ambala, 45 km from here, was stopped at different gates of the institute due to which crucial time was wasted.

‘We came near the PGIMER when the prime minister’s motorcade was entering. The road near the emergency was sealed by police and we were told to use another gate. At that gate we were told to go to a third place and then directed to go to the original gate. This delayed our reaching the hospital and he died,’ Richa Verma, a relative, told media.

Verma was suffering from a major kidney ailment and had breathing trouble. He is survived by his wife and two children.

Manmohan Singh arrived here Tuesday morning for the 44th convocation of the PGIMER.

PGIMER officials were not available for comment as they were busy with the prime minister’s visit.